By Daniel Morgan-Williams, Founding Director, Visualise Training and Consultancy Ltd.
An appraisal is a conversation about what someone has done, held in a room, at pace, under conditions that suit people who hear easily. For an employee with hearing loss, the review itself can become the barrier. The manager asks a question, the answer is shaped by what was caught rather than what was said, and the rating that follows records the strain of the meeting as much as the quality of the work.
Training courses carry the same risk. A trainer who talks while facing a screen, a group discussion with four voices at once, a video with no captions: each one asks the employee to do extra work just to take part. This guide sets out how to run appraisals, performance reviews and training so that Deaf employees and employees with hearing loss are judged on their work, and what HR, occupational health and case managers should check when a review or a course has gone badly.
Why reviews and courses carry particular risk
Most hearing loss adjustments are designed around daily work: the desk, the phone, the team meeting. Appraisals and training sit outside that routine. They are held less often, arranged by someone other than the line manager, and rarely included when adjustments are first agreed. The employee who copes well day to day can find the annual review is the one setting where nothing has been put in place.
Three features make them harder than ordinary conversation. They are dense, because a lot is covered in a short time. They are sensitive, because feedback is delivered in a lowered or careful voice, often with the manager looking at notes. And they carry consequences, because the employee knows that a missed word could be read as disagreement, disengagement or a lack of insight. Many people with hearing loss respond by nodding along. That is not agreement. It is a coping strategy, and it leaves the manager with a record of a review that went smoothly when it did not.
There is a second problem upstream. If meetings during the year were not accessible, the objectives, ratings and feedback that arrive at review may partly reflect that. A rating for collaboration or stakeholder communication, for example, may measure how well the environment worked rather than how well the employee communicated. Acas guidance on managing performance when someone is disabled advises employers to talk about how the person is currently performing, what is expected, and what support and reasonable adjustments might help, to keep an open mind, and never to assume someone is not capable of doing their job. Those points apply directly to the review conversation.
Before the review: set it up properly
The simplest step is the one most often skipped: ask the employee how they would like the review to be run. RNID guidance for employers makes the same point, that each person’s experience of hearing loss differs and managers should ask rather than assume. A short conversation a week beforehand usually settles the practical questions.
- Agree the format. Face to face, video call or a mix, and whether the employee wants communication support in the room.
- Book any communication support early. A British Sign Language interpreter, a lipspeaker, an electronic note taker or a speech-to-text reporter all need notice. RNID lists these among the professional services an employer can use.
- Choose the room with care. Quiet, well lit, no window behind the manager, and seating that lets the employee see faces clearly. Check any hearing loop is working beforehand.
- Send written material in advance: the questions, the form, the manager’s draft comments if they exist, in a format the employee can use.
- Allow more time than usual and agree breaks. Extended listening is tiring, and a review that overruns tends to get worse as it goes.
- For video reviews, agree cameras on, one speaker at a time, and live captions switched on.
During and after: keeping the record fair
In the meeting, the manager can do a lot by changing very little. Face the employee when speaking. Pause between topics so the employee can catch up. Check understanding by asking the employee to summarise the next steps rather than asking whether they have understood, which usually draws a polite yes. Write the key points down as they are agreed.
Afterwards, send a written summary and invite corrections. This protects both sides. It gives the employee a chance to put right anything misheard, and it gives the employer a record that reflects what was actually discussed. Acas advises keeping a record of what has been discussed and agreeing it with the person, which is exactly what this does.
Ratings deserve a second look. Before a rating is finalised, check whether adjustments were in place during the review period, and whether the objectives that scored poorly depended heavily on spoken communication in settings that were not adjusted. If targets were set during a gap, for instance while waiting for equipment or communication support to arrive, the target may need revisiting rather than the employee.
Training courses and development
GOV.UK guidance on reasonable adjustments states that the duty applies to all workers, including trainees and apprentices. In practice, training is where adjustments are most often missed, because the course belongs to an outside provider and the employer assumes the provider will cope.
Tell the provider in good time, with the employee’s agreement. Ask for slides and handouts in advance, captioned video, and a plan for group work and breakout sessions so the employee is not left guessing which voice to follow. Where an assessment at the end is oral, ask whether it can be given in another way. If the course is online, check that live captioning is available and works before the first session, not during it.
Employees should be able to choose how much the provider is told. Acas guidance on disabled people at work says employers should be sensitive and take the person’s lead on how much they want to share about their disability. A provider usually needs to know what support is required, not the history behind it.
Who pays for communication support?
This is a common sticking point, and the sources do not frame it identically. Section 20(7) of the Equality Act 2010 says an employer cannot require a disabled person to pay any of the costs of complying with the duty. Acas states that the employer is responsible for paying for reasonable adjustments, and that Access to Work is not a substitute for that legal obligation. The GOV.UK Access to Work pages say the scheme will not pay for reasonable adjustments, and that it will advise an employer if changes should be made as reasonable adjustments. RNID, on the other hand, describes Access to Work as designed to help organisations cover the cost of more expensive adjustments, such as professional communication support.
Those positions are not easy to reconcile in every case, and where a grant is available and how it interacts with the employer’s duty can depend on the circumstances. The two GOV.UK pages read for this article name support workers such as a BSL interpreter and specialist equipment, but do not mention training courses or meetings specifically. Whether a particular review or course is covered is best confirmed with Access to Work directly, and the employer should not delay arranging support while waiting for an answer.
The legal frame, briefly
Under the Equality Act 2010 in England, Scotland and Wales, the duty to make reasonable adjustments has three requirements: where a provision, criterion or practice puts a disabled person at a substantial disadvantage compared with people who are not disabled, where a physical feature does, and where the absence of an auxiliary aid does. An auxiliary aid includes an auxiliary service. An appraisal process or a training policy is a practice, so it falls within the first requirement. Section 21 provides that failing to comply with the duty is a failure to make reasonable adjustments, and that this is discrimination.
Acas says the duty applies when an employer knows, or could reasonably be expected to know, that someone is disabled. Whether an individual employee is covered, and what is reasonable for a particular employer, depends on the circumstances. Northern Ireland has separate legislation, and Ireland has its own framework; neither has been reviewed for this article. This article is general information and not legal advice.
What this means for occupational health, HR and case managers
When an employee with hearing loss is referred after a poor review, a dip in ratings or a stalled development plan, the first question is not what is wrong with the employee. It is what the review and the preceding year were built on. Was the process adjusted? Were adjustments in place for the meetings that fed it? Who decided the objectives, and were they set with the hearing loss in mind?
Acas says a formal capability or performance procedure should be a last resort, and that before one begins the employer should have done all it reasonably can to support the person. Evidence that adjustments were reviewed, and whether they helped, is part of that picture. A hearing loss workplace assessment can identify the specific barriers in review meetings, group work and training, and recommend practical adjustments. The report is advice: the employer decides what is reasonable in its own setting. RNID also advises that adjustments are reviewed regularly because needs change, and a written record, sometimes called an adjustment passport, makes that easier to sustain across managers.
Summary
Appraisals and training depend on live speech, which is exactly where unadjusted hearing loss does most damage. Ask the employee how they want the review run, book communication support early, choose the room and the format with care, share written material in advance and confirm outcomes in writing. Look at ratings in light of the adjustments that were or were not in place, and treat capability action as a last resort.
If you or someone in your team is Deaf or has hearing loss and would like expert, tailored support to stay productive and comfortable at work, visit our hearing loss workplace assessment page to arrange a hearing loss workplace assessment.
Frequently asked questions
Does an employer have to adjust an appraisal for an employee with hearing loss?
Where an employee is disabled within the meaning of the Equality Act 2010 and the employer knows, or could reasonably be expected to know, the duty to make reasonable adjustments can apply to the appraisal process. What counts as reasonable depends on the role, the organisation and the individual. This is general information, not advice on a specific case.
Can an employee ask for an interpreter or note taker at a performance review?
An employee can ask. RNID lists BSL interpreters, lipspeakers, electronic note takers and speech-to-text reporters as communication support an employer can use. Whether a particular form of support is reasonable depends on the circumstances, so the request should lead to a conversation about what the employee needs.
Who pays for communication support at a training course?
Acas says the employer is responsible for paying for reasonable adjustments, and that Access to Work does not replace that obligation. Access to Work may be able to help with some support costs, and RNID describes it as helping with more expensive adjustments. The scheme should be asked directly about a specific course.
Should the training provider be told about the employee’s hearing loss?
Only with the employee’s agreement and only as far as needed. The provider usually needs to know what support to arrange, not the details of the condition. Acas advises taking the person’s lead on how much they want to share.
Can a poor appraisal rating lead to a capability process?
Acas says formal procedures should be a last resort, and that employers should have done all they reasonably can to support a disabled employee beforehand, including reviewing whether adjustments have helped. Whether any process is fair in a particular case depends on the facts.
What does a hearing loss workplace assessment look at?
It looks at the employee’s actual working day, including meetings, reviews, calls and training, and recommends practical adjustments. Assessments take about two hours and the written report follows within ten working days. The recommendations are advice, and the employer decides what is reasonable.
Sources
- Equality Act 2010, section 20: legislation.gov.uk
- Equality Act 2010, section 21: legislation.gov.uk
- GOV.UK, Reasonable adjustments for workers with disabilities or health conditions: gov.uk
- GOV.UK, Access to Work, what you will get: gov.uk
- Acas, Reasonable adjustments: acas.org.uk
- Acas, Capability and performance, supporting disabled people at work: acas.org.uk
- RNID, Reasonable adjustments for employers: rnid.org.uk
- RNID, Providing communication support: rnid.org.uk
- RNID, Your rights at work: rnid.org.uk
Source notes: no guidance was found that addresses appraisals or training courses for employees with hearing loss specifically. The Acas capability page does not mention hearing loss, and the RNID pages do not set out appraisal-specific advice, so the practical steps above apply general reasonable adjustment principles to those settings. Acas guidance on performance management was read as published, and its wording is worth re-checking on the live page before it is relied on. The GOV.UK Access to Work pages do not state a grant cap or decision times, so none are given.
Photo: Ninthgrid on Unsplash.
