A computer on a desk in a bright, airy office

“But You Managed It Yesterday”: Fluctuating Sight and Hearing Loss at Work

By Daniel Morgan-Williams, Founding Director, Visualise Training and Consultancy Ltd

A computer on a desk in a bright, airy office
Photo by Alesia Kazantceva on Unsplash

On Monday, Aisha reads the weekly report on her screen without any trouble. On Tuesday, sitting at a different desk near a window, she asks for it in a larger format. Her manager is puzzled. Nothing about the report has changed, so why does she suddenly need it differently?

Down the corridor, Tom follows a one-to-one conversation with his supervisor easily, then spends the afternoon team meeting asking people to repeat themselves. A colleague mutters that he seemed fine this morning.

Moments like these are among the most common sources of misunderstanding for people with sight or hearing loss at work. They can lead to frustration on both sides, doubts about whether someone is really struggling, and in the worst cases to unfair judgements about performance or attitude. In most cases the explanation is simple: sight and hearing are affected by the setting, the task and the time of day, not just by the condition itself.

This guide explains why ability can vary, what factors make the biggest difference, and how managers, HR and occupational health teams can respond in a way that is fair and practical.

Why sight and hearing do not work the same way every day

It is natural to assume that if someone can do something once, they can do it every time. For people with sight or hearing loss, that assumption often does not hold. The condition may be stable, but the conditions around it are not.

For people with sight loss

  • Light and glare. Bright sunlight through a window, reflections on a screen or a dimly lit corner can make the difference between reading comfortably and not reading at all. Some people need a lot of light; others are very sensitive to it.
  • Contrast. Grey text on a white background, faint print, coloured charts and handwritten notes can be far harder to read than clear black text.
  • Size and layout. A well-spaced document may be easy, while a dense spreadsheet with small text and many columns is exhausting.
  • Familiarity. A familiar route around the office can be managed confidently. A new building, a rearranged room or a temporary obstruction can be much harder.
  • Changes through the day. Some eye conditions cause vision to fluctuate, and many people find their eyes tire as the day goes on.

For people with hearing loss

  • Number of speakers. A quiet conversation with one person is very different from a meeting where several people talk, interrupt or speak from across the room.
  • Background noise. Air conditioning, open-plan chatter, traffic or a busy canteen can drown out speech, even for people with good hearing technology.
  • Acoustics. Rooms with hard surfaces and echo make speech harder to separate.
  • Visual cues. Many people rely partly on lipreading. A speaker who turns away, covers their mouth or sits with a bright window behind them takes those cues away.
  • Calls and connections. A clear phone line or a good video connection can be manageable; a poor line or a call with no video can be very difficult.

Fatigue affects everyone

Concentrating to see or hear takes extra effort. A short task may be easy, while a full day of screen reading, lipreading or listening in noise can leave someone exhausted. That tiredness then makes the next task harder. It is one of the most common reasons why someone copes in the morning and struggles by the afternoon.

Why “but you managed it yesterday” causes harm

When a manager or colleague questions why someone needs help today when they did not yesterday, the person can feel disbelieved. They may start hiding difficulties rather than asking for what they need, which can lead to mistakes, stress and longer-term problems. Some people stop requesting adjustments altogether because they do not want to be seen as inconsistent.

It can also lead to unfair decisions. A manager who concludes that someone is not trying, or is making excuses, may start an informal or formal process that does not address the real barrier.

Better questions to ask

Instead of focusing on what the person managed before, focus on what is different now. Helpful questions include:

  • “What’s different about this situation?”
  • “Is something in the room making it harder today?”
  • “Would another format, another place or another way of communicating help?”
  • “Are there particular times of day or types of task that are harder?”

These questions are neutral and practical. They do not require the person to explain their condition, and they usually lead straight to a solution.

Practical adjustments for variable situations

Because the difficulty depends on the setting, adjustments often need to be flexible rather than fixed.

SituationPossible adjustments
Glare or changing lightBlinds, a desk away from windows, adjustable task lighting, screen filters, dark mode
Hard-to-read documentsDigital copies the person can enlarge, clear fonts, good contrast, information sent in advance
Unfamiliar placesOrientation before meetings or events in new buildings, clear directions, a colleague to meet them
Busy meetingsOne speaker at a time, good lighting on faces, a quieter room, remote microphones, written actions
CallsVideo where possible, a quiet space, headsets compatible with hearing aids, follow-up in writing
FatigueBreaks between demanding tasks, varied workloads, flexible hours, hybrid working where it helps

Build flexibility into the plan

When agreeing adjustments, plan for the harder situations as well as the everyday ones. A screen magnifier may work well at the usual desk, but what happens when the person hot-desks, works from home or attends a training day at another site? A remote microphone may solve team meetings, but what about the annual conference or the noisy staff canteen?

A good adjustment plan considers the full range of the person’s work, not just their typical day.

Let the person adjust as they go

Where possible, give the employee the freedom to make small changes themselves: moving to a quieter room, asking for information in a different format, closing a blind or taking a short break. When people know they can do this without having to justify it each time, they are more likely to manage their own needs effectively.

What managers can do

  • Assume good faith. Variation is normal. It is not a sign that someone is exaggerating.
  • Talk about patterns, not incidents. A calm conversation about which situations are harder is more useful than questioning one difficult day.
  • Agree a simple way to flag difficulties, such as a quick message or a word before a meeting, so the person does not have to explain each time.
  • Share information in advance wherever possible. It removes many of the hardest moments.
  • Review regularly. Some conditions change over time, and the right adjustments may need updating.

What this means for HR, occupational health and case managers

For referrers, fluctuating ability is a common source of confusion in case notes and performance discussions. A few points help:

  • Ask about the settings, not just the diagnosis. The same person may need different support in different places and tasks.
  • Look at fatigue. Difficulties that worsen through the day or week often point to the effort of coping, not to a lack of capability.
  • Be cautious about performance conclusions. Inconsistent performance can reflect an unaddressed barrier rather than motivation.
  • Use a specialist assessment to map the person’s duties and identify the situations where support is most needed. An assessment can look at lighting, acoustics, equipment and working patterns across the role, not just at the desk.

Our case study on fluctuating vision for hybrid workers shows how this works in practice.

Your legal position

In Great Britain, the Equality Act 2010 recognises that the effects of a condition can fluctuate. A condition can still count as a disability where its effects come and go, and employers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments for disabled employees. Similar principles apply in many other countries. This article is general information, not legal advice, and what is reasonable depends on the circumstances.

Summary

Sight and hearing do not work the same way in every setting or at every time of day. Light, contrast, noise, the number of speakers, familiarity and fatigue all make a difference. “But you managed it yesterday” is rarely fair or helpful. Asking what is different, building flexibility into adjustments and letting the person adapt as they go will usually solve the problem quickly.

If you or someone in your team has sight or hearing loss and would like expert, tailored support to stay productive and comfortable at work, visit our workplace assessments page to arrange a workplace assessment.

Frequently asked questions

Why can someone with sight loss read something one day but not the next?

Reading depends on lighting, glare, contrast, text size and tiredness as well as on the person’s sight. A change in any of these can make the same task much harder.

Why does someone with hearing loss cope in one conversation but not in a meeting?

One-to-one conversations in a quiet room are much easier than meetings with several speakers, background noise, poor acoustics or people speaking without facing the listener.

Does a fluctuating condition count as a disability?

In Great Britain, the Equality Act 2010 can cover conditions whose effects fluctuate, as long as they meet the definition of disability. It depends on the individual circumstances.

How should a manager respond when an employee’s needs seem inconsistent?

Ask what is different about the situation, focus on patterns rather than single incidents, and agree flexible adjustments that cover the harder situations as well as the everyday ones.

Sources

  • Equality Act 2010, legislation.gov.uk.
  • Equality and Human Rights Commission, Employment Statutory Code of Practice.