By Daniel Morgan-Williams, Founding Director, Visualise Training and Consultancy Ltd.
One employer approves a screen magnifier without a second thought. Another says it is too expensive. Both believe they are meeting their duties under the Equality Act 2010. How is that possible?
The answer lies in one small but powerful word: ‘reasonable’. When it comes to workplace adjustments for disabled employees, ‘reasonable’ is the legal standard, but it is also one of the most open-ended terms in UK employment law. It means different things to different employers, and as a result, the same need can be met with enthusiasm in one workplace and dismissed in another.
This article is general information, not legal advice. How the law applies in any individual case depends on the circumstances.
The Intention of the Equality Act 2010
The Equality Act 2010 was a landmark piece of legislation that consolidated and strengthened previous laws to protect people from discrimination. One of its key principles is that employers must make reasonable adjustments to remove barriers for employees with disabilities. This has helped countless people access equipment, changes to working practices, or physical modifications to their workspace. The Act applies in England, Scotland and Wales; Northern Ireland and Ireland have their own legislation.
However, while the law was intended to be flexible and adaptable, the lack of a clear definition for ‘reasonable’ has created a patchwork of experiences, and not all of them are positive.
What the Law Does Say
The duty is set out in section 20 of the Act. Where a provision, criterion or practice, a physical feature or the lack of an auxiliary aid puts a disabled person at a substantial disadvantage compared with people who are not disabled, the employer must take reasonable steps to avoid that disadvantage. The employer cannot require the disabled person to pay any of the cost.
The Act does not define ‘reasonable’, but the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s Employment Code lists the factors a tribunal considers: whether the step would be effective, how practicable it is, its financial and other costs and any disruption, the employer’s resources, outside help such as Access to Work, and the type and size of the employer. The Commission describes this as an objective test. A tribunal decides for itself what would have been reasonable, rather than deferring to the employer’s view.
So the legal test is not simply a matter of opinion. The difficulty is that most adjustment decisions are made long before any tribunal is involved, by a line manager, an HR adviser or a budget holder who has to apply a broad test to a specific request. Acas research on disability discrimination tribunal claims noted that what counts as reasonable can feel subjective and is not clearly defined in law, and found that disputes often centred on whether an adjustment was suitable.
The Problem with ‘Reasonable’
‘Reasonable’ is influenced by many factors: the size of the company, its financial resources, the role in question, and even the personal attitude of the decision-maker. What one HR manager or health and safety lead sees as a minor, low-cost improvement, another might view as an unnecessary expense.
This means that two employees, in similar roles and with identical needs, could receive very different levels of support simply because their employers interpret the word differently. For the individual, this can feel deeply unfair. For the organisation, it can mean losing skilled people who could have thrived with the proper support.
The Human Impact of Subjective Standards
The ambiguity of ‘reasonable’ can have significant human consequences. Employees may feel undervalued or excluded when their requests are denied on grounds they see as arbitrary. Over time, this erodes trust, damages morale, and can lead to increased turnover.
In some cases, employees don’t even request adjustments because they fear being seen as a burden or worry they’ll be told their needs are ‘unreasonable’. This means that issues like deteriorating eyesight or hearing loss often go unaddressed until they have a significant impact on health, safety, and productivity.
Why It Matters to Everyone
This isn’t just about individual rights. It’s about organisational success. Inclusive, accessible workplaces benefit everyone, not just those with a disability. Small changes can lead to better communication, fewer mistakes, improved wellbeing, and higher retention.
When ‘reasonable’ is interpreted too narrowly, employers miss out on these benefits and risk creating a culture where only those who fit a narrow definition of ‘average’ can thrive.
Delay Is Part of the Problem
Reasonableness is not only about what is agreed. It is also about how long it takes. Access to Work can fund practical support, but GOV.UK is clear that it does not pay for reasonable adjustments, the changes an employer must legally make. The National Audit Office found that the average Access to Work processing time rose from 28 days in 2020 to 2021 to 66 days in 2024 to 2025, and reached 109 days in November 2025. An employer who waits for a grant decision before deciding what is reasonable can leave a barrier in place for months.
How We Could Improve the Standard
The aim isn’t to criticise the Equality Act, but to evolve how it is applied for the realities of today. We have more technology, more data, and more awareness than ever before, so our approach to adjustments should reflect that.
Here are some steps that could help:
- Develop more explicit sector-specific guidance for what counts as reasonable.
- Create a baseline list of standard adjustments that should almost always be approved.
- Involve people with lived experience in setting and reviewing standards.
- Encourage proactive assessments so adjustments are offered before problems escalate.
The Role of Leaders and Decision-Makers
Ultimately, legislation provides the framework, but leaders decide how it’s applied in practice. HR professionals, health and safety teams, and managers all have the power to interpret ‘reasonable’ in a way that empowers rather than restricts.
By taking a proactive, empathetic, and consistent approach to adjustments, organisations can go beyond compliance and demonstrate a genuine commitment to inclusion.
What This Means for Occupational Health, HR and Case Managers
Consistency is easier when the reasoning is written down. For each request, record the barrier, the task it affects, the options considered and how each of the Commission’s factors applied. That record protects the employee, the line manager and the organisation, and it makes the next decision quicker.
It also helps to separate two questions that are often blurred: what would remove the barrier, and whether the organisation can reasonably do it. A specialist report can answer the first question by describing the barrier and the adjustment by feature, so that decision-makers are weighing a clear recommendation rather than a vague request. The second question then belongs to the employer. Case managers and insurers can help by asking early whether the adjustment has been identified, who owns it and when it will be in place.
How a Workplace Assessment Helps
A Visualise Training and Consultancy Ltd workplace assessment for an employee with sight loss or hearing loss takes about two hours, is carried out virtually or face to face, and covers the UK and Ireland. The employee is contacted within two working days of the referral and the report follows within ten working days. The fee is £795 for a virtual assessment and £995 for a face-to-face assessment, with no VAT. The report goes to the referrer, and the recommendations are advice: the employer still decides what is reasonable. What the report adds is a clear, specialist description of the barrier and the options, which is the information a fair decision needs.
Summary
‘Reasonable’ was always meant to be a flexible, adaptable term, but when flexibility turns into inconsistency, it’s time to talk about change. Updating how we define and apply this standard could remove unnecessary barriers, unlock potential, and create fairer, more productive workplaces.
The law does give a structure for judging what is reasonable. The inconsistency lies in how that structure is applied day to day, and written reasoning, clear specialist advice and prompt decisions would narrow the gap between the best and the worst experiences.
What’s the most ‘unreasonable’ reasonable adjustment you’ve seen or experienced? And how would you modify the system to ensure that everyone has a fair chance to succeed?
If you or someone in your team has sight loss or hearing loss and would like expert, tailored support to stay productive and comfortable at work, visit https://visualisetrainingandconsultancy.com/workplace-assessments/ to arrange a workplace assessment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does ‘reasonable’ mean in the Equality Act 2010?
The Act does not define it. The Equality and Human Rights Commission’s Employment Code lists factors such as effectiveness, practicability, cost, the employer’s resources and available outside help, and the test is objective.
Does a small employer have to make the same adjustments as a large one?
The duty applies to all employers, but the type and size of the employer, and its resources, are among the factors considered when deciding what is reasonable.
Can cost alone be a reason to refuse?
Cost is one factor. It is considered alongside the employer’s resources, how effective the step would be and any outside help available, such as Access to Work.
Can an employer ask the employee to contribute?
No. Section 20 of the Equality Act 2010 says the employer cannot require the disabled person to pay any of the cost of complying with the duty.
Sources
- Equality Act 2010, section 20 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Equality and Human Rights Commission, Proving disability and reasonable adjustments
- Acas, Characteristics and drivers of disability discrimination employment tribunal claims
- Access to Work factsheet for employers (GOV.UK)
- National Audit Office, Access to Work processing delays
